[智力测试]请问说真话的孩子是谁，打碎玻璃的又是谁?

如來彿祖

A、B、C、D4个孩子在院子里踢足球，把一户人家的玻璃打碎了。可是当房主人问他们是谁踢的球把玻璃打碎的，他们谁也不承认是自己打碎的。房主人问A，A说：“是C打的。”C则说“A说的不符合事实。”房主人又问B，B说：“不是我打的。”再问D，D说是“A打的。”已经知道这4个孩子当中有1个很老实、不会说假话：其余3个都不老实，都说的是假话。请问说真话的孩子是谁，打碎玻璃的又是谁?& i+ s, g8 d& y& T
5.39.217.768 e2 j, f+ v, G4 r, e" A
7 e+ H4 m( V: p+ l

, x3 H0 D+ S9 o# D

本帖隱藏的內容需要回復才可以瀏覽

taxidoor

a ba

爱情-天使

B、:onion14:

manstein

Assume A is correct, den B is oso correct, therefore not the rite answer
) g  m% U$ V& x$ o1 H- [9 Q$ j7 dAssume B is correct, den assume A is lying, den the culprit is either A or D, den if D is oso lying, den the culprit is either C or D, den C cannot b lying...becuz if A is lying means tat C is correct...公仔箱論壇/ Z7 H  y. e1 \8 C8 x
Assume C is correct, den A is lying, so the culprit is either A, B or D, if B is lying, means tat the culprit is himself, den if D is lying oso den the answer is B, C or D. D' p4 K+ e3 Z6 y& p( ]7 u" O
Assume D is correct, den the culprit is A but den in that case B n C r oso correct...
) s6 [" U- g' |: S) n9 u5.39.217.76) g; L5 l4 R$ J3 `3 v: v& g6 M# w
So the ACTUAL CULPRIT is B公仔箱論壇5 u0 B  @; V) |
  K9 q4 I7 w) B

25206550

五系好识涡

yfgary

B....
. _, D( {, T, L3 Y7 }# W6 H: @- T- m5.39.217.76only C said the real, all other 3 ppl is tell lei

vtckeith

don't know

alex8889

B、

ailin

b

kerry0215

:019: B挂

g1wah

should be "B"

sy.r18

:onion03: :onion03: :onion03:

ivhku2

估到A/D...../ f1 m' h  O( c4 j  C
D打醉玻璃~
* E; C3 F- h8 H# h$ s; c  u7 A/ \B講真話