Board logo

標題: [硬碟] SEAGATE Harddisk or Western Digital Harddisk better? [打印本頁]

作者: superiii    時間: 2007-2-10 05:38 PM     標題: SEAGATE Harddisk or Western Digital Harddisk better?

which one better?
作者: 天一    時間: 2007-2-10 09:19 PM

梧同人有晤同geh喜好。。。。
我就觉得WD比较好啦。。。。。
作者: saga2005    時間: 2007-2-10 09:44 PM

seagate 唔係人用架wo..
作者: AhChow    時間: 2007-2-11 12:10 PM

oh no.. I got couple seagate hard drive.. probably I am a ghost then..
作者: geniepo    時間: 2007-2-11 03:45 PM

both okla.......but WD seems better in the long run
作者: cashcow    時間: 2007-2-12 08:29 PM

I'll stay with Seagate.  WD is so unreliable!!!! Beware!
作者: asus_p2_vb    時間: 2007-2-12 09:46 PM

last time im use wd suddenly wouldn't run any more thn waste my $ to buy it X(
however seagate in process the temperature is higher thn wd but overall is better thn wd
作者: felimckkion    時間: 2007-2-13 11:54 AM

Personally I have very good experience with WD, extremely reliable.
But Seagate is not bad either.
If you want big HD, e.g. 750 GB, Seagate has it but not WD.
作者: yaoming2k2    時間: 2007-2-13 10:22 PM

i m using seagate now
作者: jwxie518    時間: 2007-2-14 09:05 AM

基本上兩個都差唔多
seg呢個brand好耐了, 有老字號的感覺
但其實WD都唔錯
之前COMPARE D PRICE, 兩個都差多價錢
至於效能, 如果你真係想話"保險"咪買SEG....
但係我個人無乜所謂

當然我有聽過幾個朋友話SEG好

HARD DISK選邊一個BRAND, 只要係 SEG / WD都冇問題
唔需要特別去問嫁^^
作者: pricyber    時間: 2007-2-21 05:20 AM

Seagate 5 year warranty.
I have 2x Seagate (on Raid 0)
and 1x WD (storage)
no problem on both.
作者: Beautylui    時間: 2007-3-1 10:47 AM     標題: 回復第 1 帖由 superiii 所發的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: Addo    時間: 2007-3-10 07:03 PM

看不懂~~
作者: ecnam    時間: 2007-3-11 01:29 AM

SEAGATE Harddisk will betterla
作者: khoko    時間: 2007-3-12 04:53 AM

你們可以去consumer report.org睇下囉。
WD係好多訴架!!
作者: khoko    時間: 2007-3-12 04:54 AM

如果價錢相約﹐我就買Seagate啦﹐我自己都有一個Seagate external。
作者: jwxie518    時間: 2007-3-12 07:18 AM

原帖由 khoko 於 2007-3-11 03:53 PM 發表。
你們可以去consumer report.org睇下囉。
WD係好多訴架!!
基本上所有野都係咁,哈哈
就好像係newegg.com想買個power supply
之前朋友同我講佢個個POWER supply就係成日俾人投訴, 差唔多個個人話 垃圾....
個種power supply係連case, 所以好差
但佢部機係 雙顯示卡, 差唔多24小時開機, 有次落大雨行雷, 佢部機仲即刻熄左
佢話用左成2年都冇事
人地就1個月死左

基本上好多野都係睇好唔好彩
不過我同意你講, 價錢相若, 買 SEG係個好選擇, 反正係老大.....

[ 本帖最後由 jwxie518 於 2007-3-11 06:19 PM 編輯 ]
作者: han1128    時間: 2007-4-3 09:48 PM

seagate
作者: benny0105    時間: 2007-4-6 11:12 AM

我有個WD行左6年左右,非常正常 \:D/

不過另一個WD行左2個月都無就死左.. [-X

我有過10隻HD:

7 x WD       死過一隻
1 x SG        未死過
2 x Maxtor   死過一隻

綜合以往經驗:

Maxtor=唔好!發出太高溫!
SG= 可以試,不過最好用行貨
WD= 極力推薦,溫度低又靜,但係一定要買行貨
作者: cicipizza    時間: 2007-4-20 04:52 AM

Both are bad! Maxtor is the best
1. Maxtor
2. Seagate
3 WD (too noisy)
作者: cicipizza    時間: 2007-4-20 04:57 AM

Agree with benny0105 about WD HD.
At the year 1999-2001 WD was the best, but after [-X
It made too many nois and also bad sectors
作者: alvin5147    時間: 2007-4-20 09:05 PM

Segate is better than WD, segate more stable, and when ghost pc, segate is fast about 30% compare than WD...
作者: lineage    時間: 2007-4-22 07:42 AM

hao
作者: cheehock91    時間: 2007-4-29 10:47 AM

wd better




歡迎光臨 公仔箱論壇 (http://5.39.217.76/) Powered by Discuz! 7.0.0